Video Models
Frog travelers at a harbor, same prompt — Grok Imagine vs Seedance 2.5
Scoreboard2
- Grok ImaginexAI
- Written just as "Grok" (Imagine version not stated). Clip 1 (720×1280, 15 s); clip order inferred from the post's critique (changed character look, fruit leaving the bucket, vanishing plank).
- Seedance 2.5ByteDanceAuthor’s pick
- Written as “Seedance 2.5”
- Clip 2 (480×854, 24 s).
Prompt
Frog travelers at a harbor, same promptThe post doesn’t quote the prompt wording.
Grok still trails Seedance 2.5: it changed the reference character's look, broke physics (fruit jumping out of a bucket, a plank vanishing) and gave flatter facial expressions.
@Morley_Zhou’s view (paraphrased)
Grok Imagine and Seedance 2.5 get the exact same prompt and two frog character reference sheets for an anime-style harbor scene. The author lists where Grok fell short: character fidelity, physics and facial detail.
The post, itemised
- Kind
- Side-by-side
- Task
- Frog travelers at a harbor, same prompt
- Category
- Video Models
- Mode
- Not stated
- Posted
- Video length
- 15 s (+1 more clip)
- Likes
- 2
- Views
- 15
- Sponsored
- No
Cost & time, as stated in the postSame prompt and the same two character reference images for both; the post also attaches the two reference sheets (not shown here).
Related
Content belongs to its creators. Video by @Morley_Zhou; aivs.tv hosts a copy for fast playback and links to the original post on X. Request removal
