Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen

aka Carbon vs Google Gemini 4 Hydrogen

17 posts702 likes84.9K views

  • Author picksEven1–1
  • CheaperEven1–1
  • FasterGemini 4 Hydrogen2/2 postsmedian gap ~1.5×

As stated in each post, not a controlled benchmark.

Posts

17

Same prompt, separate runs

2

Not a controlled comparison: prompts, tools and time differ.

About this matchup

Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen in real side-by-side tests: 17 posts from X where both got the same prompt; 4 posts report cost or time. Judge coding ability from the actual outputs.

Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen: which is better for coding?

Which is better for coding, Gemini 4 Carbon or Gemini 4 Hydrogen?

Author picks: where the author preferred one of the two, they picked Gemini 4 Carbon once and Gemini 4 Hydrogen once. That covers 2 of the 17 posts here; each post is a different task, so watch the outputs above for the work you care about.

Which is cheaper, Gemini 4 Carbon or Gemini 4 Hydrogen?

2 posts state a cost for both: each was cheaper in 1. These are the costs the posts state for each run, not list prices.

Which is faster, Gemini 4 Carbon or Gemini 4 Hydrogen?

2 posts state a time for both: Gemini 4 Hydrogen was faster in both (median gap ~1.5×). Times are as stated in each post; tools and settings differ between posts.

Summary

Gemini 4 Carbon and Gemini 4 Hydrogen appear together in 17 posts on X: lava lamp, Neon / Carbon / Hydrogen (@aaronolin), gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Argon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen (@srikanthvaluri), espresso pull from a bottomless basket (@teddyaisi), lava folding down rock steps in a basalt gorge (@teddyaisi), glass prism sweeping a spectrum across a screen (@teddyaisi) and 12 more. 14 of them are part of larger lineups with other models. In @noclipepe's Up house, same prompt and reference, Gemini 4 Hydrogen was cheaper ($1.09 vs $1.90) and faster (12.8 min vs 24.8 min), as reported in the post. In @Offloop's four whales making a splash, Gemini 4 Carbon was cheaper ($0.34 vs $0.44) and Gemini 4 Hydrogen was faster (5.4 min vs 6 min), as reported in the post.

What each post reports

Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen: cost, time and tokens as stated in each post
PostModelTimeCostTokensAuthor’s verdictPost
Lava lamp, Neon / Carbon / Hydrogen@aaronolinGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Lava lamp, Neon / Carbon / Hydrogen@aaronolinGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Argon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen@srikanthvaluriGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Gemini 4 Carbon vs Gemini 4 Argon vs Gemini 4 Hydrogen@srikanthvaluriGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Espresso pull from a bottomless basket@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Espresso pull from a bottomless basket@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Lava folding down rock steps in a basalt gorge@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Lava folding down rock steps in a basalt gorge@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Glass prism sweeping a spectrum across a screen@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Glass prism sweeping a spectrum across a screen@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Octopus pulling itself along a reef ravine@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Octopus pulling itself along a reef ravine@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Macro tourbillon inside a mechanical watch@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Macro tourbillon inside a mechanical watch@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Mustard-yellow buggy on a banked dirt oval@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Mustard-yellow buggy on a banked dirt oval@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Spider-Man model in Three.js@VibeDevarfGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Spider-Man model in Three.js@VibeDevarfGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Amber glass stretching beside a midnight furnace@teddyaisiGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Amber glass stretching beside a midnight furnace@teddyaisiGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
The Up house, same prompt and reference@noclipepeGemini 4 Carbon24.8 min$1.90——X post
The Up house, same prompt and reference@noclipepeGemini 4 Hydrogen12.8 min$1.09——X post
3D medieval trebuchet castle siege@StatsWireGemini 4 Carbon————X post
3D medieval trebuchet castle siege@StatsWireGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Four whales making a splash@OffloopGemini 4 Hydrogen5.4 min$0.44——X post
Four whales making a splash@OffloopGemini 4 Carbon6 min$0.34——X post
Pelican riding a bicycle@willwang_xxGemini 4 Hydrogen110 s———X post
Pelican riding a bicycle@willwang_xxGemini 4 Carbon————X post
Lion biking and juggling across four seasons@SahilPanhotraGemini 4 Hydrogen———Gemini 4 Carbon nailed the crossing juggling arcs and added winter breath puffs; Gemini 4 Hydrogen faked the juggling by floating.X post
Lion biking and juggling across four seasons@SahilPanhotraGemini 4 Carbon———Author’s pickX post
3D horse simulation and per-token prices@FluskuGemini 4 Carbon————X post
3D horse simulation and per-token prices@FluskuGemini 4 Hydrogen————X post
Ship-in-a-bottle diorama@huang18825Gemini 4 Hydrogen4.8 min——Author’s pickX post
Ship-in-a-bottle diorama@huang18825Gemini 4 Carbon————X post

Only numbers stated in each post. “—” means the post doesn’t say.

Quick facts

ModelVendorReleasedInput $/1M tokensOutput $/1M tokensContext (tokens)Official links
Gemini 4 CarbonGoogle2026-10-28Announcement · Announcement post
Gemini 4 HydrogenGoogle2026-11-12Announcement

From the vendors’ official pages, checked 2026-11-12. Standard API list prices; each value links its source and a blank cell could not be verified. The archive’s own numbers above are what each post states.

Who won where

2

Models

Related matchups